By Yvonne Milroy
In my afterhours life I am a theatre reviewer based in Hamilton. For my website, I reduced the essence of my work down to โYou: Createy, Createy. Me: Writey, Writey.โ That summed it up in a pithy two-line description, i.e. you perform it, and I will write about it. Write On Arts
Q. Could there be an easier side hustle?
A. Yes, a thousand times yes.
Reviewing in the Waikato occurs in fits and starts. During the Hamilton Arts Festival in February/March, I may attend up to six performances in a week. At the end of Term One in April, the high schools throw open the hall doors on their seasons. This year, I was out consecutive Thursday, Friday and Saturday nights. In July/August, many local theatre companies put on a mid-year production. Weaved throughout these busy periods are smaller productions across a multitude of theatres and venues.
In 2024 I saw 43 separate productions, but more than fifty performances in total due to seeing some shows multiple times because I have been involved in the creation of the piece. At all 43 productions I was seated with my little A5 hardcover notebook and Pilot Pen
Once the performance starts, Iโm locked in, making notes about action, cast, lighting, set, costumes, hair, makeup, sound, direction, music, band, character arcs, choreography, diction, vocal technique, and more. The pages are soon filled with adjectives, thoughts, and the occasional eavesdropped comment, all scribbled as the performance unfolds. I find live performance exhilarating and leave the venue buzzing about the experience.

Once in a blue moon there will be something so glaringly ghastly in a performance that I will message the director or producer immediately and suggest a small but pertinent change. An example is โRein in the stage crew – they shouldnโt be yapping so loud backstageโ or โThere was a buzz coming from the suspended speaker on stage rightโ.
But then I come home, wash my face, tie up my hair and sit down at my laptop. And write. Well, try to write. I have a rule that my reviews are published chronologically in order of seeing a performance. This means that I cannot procrastinate and work on another review first.
Writing a review can be the most torturous process ever, especially if I am writing in the early hours and it must be completed because there are more reviews lined up. On top of that, add the fact that sometimes my notes arenโt exactly legible. And then there is the decision about do I want to stand or sit? Do I want another Coke Zero? Should I be eating lollies in the middle of the night?
In 2019 my set-up started as a laptop balanced on my knees. Then I added a gloriously clunky keyboard. And a desk. After that I needed a second screen. Then a larger desk with a built-in bookcase. Finally, an electric standing desk. Six months ago I was a three-desk household, definite overkill for just me. I wonโt mention the ergonomic mouse pad, headphones, or other extraneous items.
Surely, Yvonne, with all that investment to set up the ideal reviewing space, you would be able to crank out reviews?
Nope.
I believe that providing a blow-by-blow account of the storyline is simply a cheatโs way to meet a word count. Reviews should encompass the whole experience โ what or who was good, covering the staging, technical aspects, creative elements, and production personnel.
Given the multitude of components that can be assessed, I tend to focus on the positive, and shoutout clever technical elements that other reviewers may not notice. The leads and creative team should get a mention too. I rarely have an opportunity to read another reviewerโs point of view before my own is published.
If the show finishes at 10pm, and I am at my desk by 10:30pm, the goal is to have the review published and for me to be in bed by midnight. Nine times out of ten, I am banging my head against a brick wall with my eyeballs hanging out of their sockets at 2am, trying to assemble the last few sentences in some random paragraph.
Once the review is ready to be posted to my website, I add photos (with credits) and ticketing links. I then create a pull quote to add to social media posts and make it go live. The last step is to email the link to the producer and let them know the review is up. I do have a feeling of satisfaction once I have completed the task, and I stand by my words. It certainly isnโt easy or quick to sum up a production in 500-700 words in the middle of the night. My motivation is that reviewing is not as difficult as baring oneโs soul on stage. Now, that is the real challenge, and a good review should provide a fair and considered summary, even if it is written at 2am.









Leave a comment